The Sixth Circuit ruled an arrestee was protected by the 4th Amendment, not the 14th Amendment, when he was viciously beaten at the Montgomery County, Ohio Jail during the booking process. For the first time, the Court made clear that the 4th Amendment not only applies through the booking process, but extends until a judicial determination of probable cause occurs (e.g., arraignment, warrant). The 14th Amendment protections begin after the judicial determination and until conviction. The District Court properly denied Qualified Immunity to one defendant but the case was remanded for decision regarding the remaining defendants under the more lenient 4th Amendment reasonableness standard. The decision and other pleadings can be viewed here.


